Drug allergies and mechanisms - mechanisms
Framework
- Gell and Coombs classification - the framework for immune-mediated drug reactions
- Distinguishes true immunological hypersensitivity from non-immune adverse drug reactions (intolerance, toxicity, idiosyncratic, pseudo-allergic) - the majority of reported "allergies" are not immune-mediated at all
Over-labelling
- Reported drug allergy in ~10% of the population; true confirmed IgE-mediated allergy in <10% of those labelled
- Over-labelling (esp. penicillin) drives inferior antibiotic choice, worse infection outcomes, and antimicrobial resistance
Gell and Coombs types
| Type | Mechanism | Timing | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| I - Immediate (IgE) | Mast cell/basophil degranulation via pre-formed IgE | Minutes-1h | Anaphylaxis, urticaria, angioedema (penicillin, NMBAs) |
| II - Cytotoxic | IgG/IgM against drug-hapten on cell surface + complement | Days | Drug-induced haemolytic anaemia, thrombocytopenia (penicillin, methyldopa) |
| III - Immune complex | Antigen-antibody complexes deposit in tissue | 1-3 weeks | Serum sickness, drug-induced vasculitis, some drug fever |
| IV - Delayed (T-cell) | T-cell mediated, subtypes IVa-d | Days-weeks | Contact dermatitis, SJS/TEN, DRESS, AGEP (see below) |
Type IV subtypes - severe cutaneous adverse reactions
Type IV subtypes - relevant to severe cutaneous adverse reactions (SCARs)
- IVa (Th1/macrophage) - contact dermatitis
- IVb (Th2/eosinophil) - DRESS
- IVc (cytotoxic T-cell) - SJS/TEN
- IVd (neutrophil) - AGEP (acute generalised exanthematous pustulosis)
Non-immune mechanisms - commonly mislabelled as allergy
- Pseudo-allergic/direct mast cell activation (MRGPRX2 receptor) - opioids, vancomycin ("red man syndrome"), radiocontrast - clinically resembles Type I but not IgE-mediated
- Pharmacological side effect - ACEi cough, NSAID GI upset
- Intolerance - metallic taste, nausea
- Idiosyncratic/genetic - G6PD-related haemolysis, *HLA-B57:01 with abacavir hypersensitivity, HLA-B15:02 with carbamazepine-induced SJS/TEN in Southeast Asian populations*
History is the primary diagnostic tool
- Timing relative to dose, nature of the reaction, treatment required, and outcome - determines risk category and whether testing is needed
- Distinguish immediate (Type I pattern - urticaria, angioedema, wheeze, hypotension within 1h) from delayed (rash days into a course) from a SCAR pattern (mucosal involvement, skin pain, blistering, fever, organ involvement, eosinophilia)
Confirmatory testing (specialist-directed)
- Skin prick/intradermal testing - for suspected Type I (validated for penicillin, limited for other drugs)
- Serum tryptase - raised during/soon after a suspected anaphylactic reaction (peaks ~1-2h, returns to baseline by 24h)
- Patch testing - for delayed/contact-type reactions
- Graded/direct oral drug challenge - gold standard to confirm tolerance in low-risk histories
- HLA typing before high-risk drugs in at-risk populations (abacavir, carbamazepine)
Management by mechanism
By mechanism
- Type I - avoid the drug, treat acute reaction as anaphylaxis if severe (adrenaline IM first-line); desensitisation possible if drug essential and no alternative
- SCARs (SJS/TEN, DRESS, AGEP) - stop the culprit drug immediately, supportive care +/- burns-unit level care for TEN, avoid re-exposure to the drug and structurally related agents lifelong
- Type II/III - stop the drug, treat the immune-mediated cytopenia/vasculitis as needed
Correct mislabelling - a major stewardship intervention
- Most reported penicillin "allergy" is not IgE-mediated and delabelling improves antibiotic choice - see companion note on drug allergy assessment/delabelling
- Document the specific reaction phenotype in the record, not just "allergic" - enables future risk stratification
Risk factors and HLA associations
- Atopy - risk factor for Type I reactions, not for T-cell mediated SCARs
- Viral infection (esp. EBV, HIV) - increases risk of maculopapular drug eruptions (e.g. amoxicillin rash with EBV)
- Specific HLA alleles - abacavir (HLA-B57:01), carbamazepine/allopurinol (HLA-B15:02, HLA-B*58:01) SJS/TEN risk
Natural history
- IgE-mediated allergy can wane over years (~80% of penicillin allergy resolves by 10 years) - supports re-assessment rather than a permanent label
- SCAR reactions carry lifelong avoidance recommendations for the culprit and cross-reactive drugs - do not wane
- Accurate mechanism-based labelling materially changes lifetime antibiotic and drug choices
🔒
10 more sections, plus exam facts
Premium unlocks every note across every specialty, and the full exam fact library behind it.
Get premium access